The Ratings Game: Citi upgrades Wells Fargo, cuts view on five other banks
Citigroup analyst Keith Horowitz upgraded Wells Fargo to a buy, reiterated a bullish view on M&T Bancorp and cut ratings on five other banks on Monday.
While banks looked poised for outperformance earlier in the year, concerns over a potential economic slowdown, as well as the Ukraine war, have impacted multiples.
The key development from January has been the quick onset of inflation as a rally in bank stocks from last year turned into stock losses thus far in 2022. The Financial Select Sector SPDR ETF
is down 3.4% this year, compared to a 7.4% drop by the S&P 500
“What has changed is expectations for a rapid increase in rates, which can be problematic for some banks in the near-term and we are adjusted our ratings to build in a higher margin of safety,” Horowitz said. “Given the increased uncertainty, it becomes relatively easy to draw up a bear case on credit risk and the negative stock price action seems to reinforce the narrative as investors move to the sidelines awaiting more clarity.”
Also Read: Goldman, JPMorgan wind down Russia biz as war reshapes macroeconomic landscape for banks
Citi upgraded Wells Fargo & Co
to buy from hold on its capital flexibility and asset sensitivity and trimmed the stock’s price target to $56 from $58 a share.
Horowitz reiterated buy ratings on Bank of America Corp.
Goldman Sachs Group Inc.
M&T Bank Corp
and Regions Financial Corp.
He cut Bank of America’s price target to $47 from $57, trimmed Comerica’s price target to $110 from $115; Goldman Sachs to $400 from $455; Morgan Stanley to $100 from $125, M&T Bank to $190 from $220 and Regions Financial to $25 from $27 a share.
Citi also initiated a pair trade overweight WFC/underweight US Bancorp
“We believe the faster than expected rising rate environment will magnify balance sheet positioning and in our view Wells Fargo is among the best positioned with strong capital and liquidity, while USB is less asset sensitive so has limited upside on net interest income,” Horowitz said.
M&T Bank Corp remains Citi’s top pick given asset sensitivity, excess dry powder, and share repurchase capacity, he said.
Horowitz cut his ratings to neutral from buy on BNY Mellon Corp.
(price target lowered to $50 from $70), Citizens Financial Group
(price target lowered to $45 from $57), State Street Corp.
($93 from $120), Truist Financial Corp.
($58 from $75), and U.S. Bancorp
($53 from $65).
“While we believe the valuations on these names remain attractive, we move to the sidelines as we believe 2023 earnings per share estimates need to be reset lower and we see limited buyback capacity,” he said.
Also Read: U.S. banks are facing body blows from Ukraine war and a slump in investment banking activity